Side by Side Comparison
| Tool | Best For | Starting Price | Free Plan | Score |
|---|
| Rippling | All-in-one HR + payroll | $8/month | No | 9/10 |
| Homebase | Hourly & shift-based teams | $0/month | Yes | 9/10 |
| TestGorilla | Skills-based screening | $0/month | Yes | 8.7/10 |
| BambooHR | First-time HR platform | $6/month | No | 8.7/10 |
| Toggl Hire | Simple, affordable hiring | $0/month | Yes | 8.5/10 |
How to Pick the Right One for Your Business
If you have hourly or shift-based workers and your biggest headache is scheduling and clock-ins, start with Homebase. The free plan handles most of what you need, and you can upgrade when your team grows or you open a second location. No reason to pay for a full HR platform when your core problem is a Tuesday shift that won't fill itself.
If your team is salaried, you're past 10 people, and you're managing HR, payroll, and onboarding in spreadsheets and email threads, Rippling is the answer. Yes, it costs more and takes longer to set up. You'll make that time back within the first month, and you won't be rebuilding your stack in two years when you outgrow something cheaper.
If hiring is your primary challenge โ you're growing, getting flooded with applications, and you've made at least one expensive hiring mistake โ pair TestGorilla or Toggl Hire with a lightweight ATS. TestGorilla has the deeper test library; Toggl Hire has more complete pipeline management. Both start free.
For businesses ready to move off spreadsheets but not ready for Rippling's scope, BambooHR is the sensible middle ground. It's not the cheapest option per employee, but the time saved on onboarding admin and the clarity it brings to people management makes it worth the cost once you're past 10 employees.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do small businesses really need HR software, or is this just for larger companies?
Once you're past five employees, you're managing enough complexity โ time off, onboarding paperwork, payroll variables โ that doing it manually starts costing you real time every week. The free tiers from Homebase and Toggl Hire mean there's no financial reason to keep doing it in spreadsheets.
What's the difference between an ATS and HR software?
An ATS manages candidates before they're hired โ job postings, applications, interviews, offers. HR software manages people after they join โ records, payroll, time off, performance. Some platforms like Rippling and BambooHR do both. Others, like TestGorilla, do one thing specifically. Know which problem you're solving first.
Are free HR tools actually good enough, or do they always push you to upgrade?
Homebase and Toggl Hire have free plans that are useful for single-location businesses with modest hiring volumes. TestGorilla's free tier lets you run real assessments. None will scale indefinitely without a paid plan, but you'll get real value before you hit that ceiling.
What happened to Breezy HR and 15Five โ why aren't they in the top six?
Both are decent tools. Breezy HR scored 8.3 โ it's a solid ATS, but Toggl Hire offers comparable core features with a better free tier. 15Five, also at 8.3, is a good performance management platform, but it's narrower in scope than what most small businesses need first. Neither made the cut because the tools ranked above solve more problems for more businesses at better value.
Is the free tier on Homebase actually usable in 2026, or is it stripped down?
It is genuinely usable for one location with basic scheduling, time tracking, and hiring. The 2025 updates kept the free tier intact when most competitors trimmed theirs. You will eventually want the paid tier for labour cost tools and advanced scheduling, but the free version handles day-to-day for most small teams.
Does skills-based hiring actually improve who you hire, or is it just another hoop for candidates?
The data from businesses that have run structured assessments for 12 months or more is consistent: lower turnover in the first six months and fewer mis-hires. The caveat is that assessments need to be relevant to the actual role. Generic personality tests do not move the needle. Role-specific skills tests do.
If I am already using BambooHR, is there a reason to switch to Rippling in 2026?
Probably not unless you are also solving a payroll or IT provisioning problem. BambooHR is still strong at core HR. The switch cost โ data migration, retraining, contract timing โ is only worth it if you are buying more than the HR module from Rippling.
What is the minimum HR setup for a business with fewer than 10 people?
Homebase on the free plan for scheduling and time tracking. A basic payroll tool with auto-filing. And TestGorilla on the free tier for hiring. That combination costs nothing, takes a weekend to set up, and handles 80% of what a small team actually needs.